We compared prices across Cayman's grocery stores and found these products with the biggest price differences. Shopping at the right store for these items can save you serious money.
Top 30 Biggest Price Gaps
| Product | Cheapest | Most Expensive | You Save |
|---|
| Seasonal Gift Baskets 75 |
$12.99 (Hurley's) |
$75.00 (Foster's) |
$62.01 (83%) |
| Atomi Smart 2 Pack Light |
$99.97 (Priced Right) |
$149.99 (Foster's) |
$50.02 (33%) |
| Grace Coconut Water w/ Pulp |
$1.69 (Hurley's) |
$35.99 (Foster's) |
$34.30 (95%) |
| Chaise Lounge Chair |
$219.99 (Foster's) |
$249.99 (Priced Right) |
$30.00 (12%) |
| Muscle Mechanix Eliptical |
$189.99 (Priced Right) |
$219.99 (Foster's) |
$30.00 (14%) |
| Price R Chicken Wings Frzn |
$59.99 (Foster's) |
$89.99 (Priced Right) |
$30.00 (33%) |
| Pedigree Small Dog Adult Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor Food For Adult Dogs 56 Oz |
$9.99 (Foster's) |
$39.49 (Hurley's) |
$29.50 (75%) |
| Google Smart Light Starter Kit 1 Kit |
$24.99 (Priced Right) |
$44.99 (Foster's) |
$20.00 (44%) |
| Ks Food Saver Vacum Bags Combo |
$14.99 (Priced Right) |
$34.99 (Foster's) |
$20.00 (57%) |
| Emeril Pizza Grill Small |
$69.99 (Priced Right) |
$89.99 (Foster's) |
$20.00 (22%) |
| P/Right Whole Frozen Snapper |
$55.99 (Foster's) |
$74.99 (Priced Right) |
$19.00 (25%) |
| Ensure Original Nutrition Shake Vanilla Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$2.99 (Foster's) |
$21.09 (Hurley's) |
$18.10 (86%) |
| Ensure Original Nutrition Shake Strawberry Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$2.99 (Foster's) |
$21.09 (Hurley's) |
$18.10 (86%) |
| Glucerna Diabetes Nutritional Shake Creamy Strawberry Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$2.99 (Foster's) |
$20.79 (Hurley's) |
$17.80 (86%) |
| Ensure Nutrition Shake, Milk Chocolate, Original, 6 Pack 6 ea |
$2.99 (Foster's) |
$20.79 (Hurley's) |
$17.80 (86%) |
| Glucerna Diabetes Nutritional Shake Homemade Vanilla Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$2.99 (Foster's) |
$20.49 (Hurley's) |
$17.50 (85%) |
| Ensure Plus Nutrition Shake Strawberry Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$20.59 (Hurley's) |
$17.30 (84%) |
| Ensure Plus Nutrition Shake Vanilla Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$2.79 (Foster's) |
$19.99 (Hurley's) |
$17.20 (86%) |
| Similac Infant Formula, With Iron, Hypoallergenic, Powder, 0 12 Months 12.1 oz |
$33.79 (Foster's) |
$50.99 (Hurley's) |
$17.20 (34%) |
| Ensure Plus Nutrition Shake Milk Chocolate Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$20.49 (Hurley's) |
$17.20 (84%) |
| Badia Olive Oil, Extra Virgin 67.6 Oz |
$26.99 (Foster's) |
$43.99 (Hurley's) |
$17.00 (39%) |
| Chicken Caesar Wrap |
$7.99 (Hurley's) |
$24.99 (Foster's) |
$17.00 (68%) |
| PediaSure Grow & Gain Kids’ Nutritional Shake Chocolate Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$19.99 (Hurley's) |
$16.70 (84%) |
| PediaSure Grow & Gain Kids’ Nutritional Shake Strawberry Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$19.99 (Hurley's) |
$16.70 (84%) |
| Pedia Sure Vanilla Shake 6 ea |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$19.99 (Hurley's) |
$16.70 (84%) |
| Mistic Juice Drink, Tropical Fruit Punch 15.9 Fl Oz |
$1.59 (Foster's) |
$17.99 (Priced Right) |
$16.40 (91%) |
| PediaSure Grow & Gain with Fiber Kids’ Nutritional Shake Vanilla Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.29 (Foster's) |
$19.39 (Hurley's) |
$16.10 (83%) |
| Price R Chicken Thighs Frzn |
$38.99 (Foster's) |
$54.99 (Priced Right) |
$16.00 (29%) |
| Ensure High Protein Nutrition Shake Vanilla Ready-to-Drink 6-8 fl oz Bottles |
$3.09 (Foster's) |
$18.99 (Hurley's) |
$15.90 (84%) |
| Ensure Nutrition Shake, Milk Chocolate 6 ea |
$3.09 (Foster's) |
$18.99 (Hurley's) |
$15.90 (84%) |
Key Takeaways
- Foster's is cheapest for 22 of the top 30 price gaps
- Priced Right is cheapest for 5 of the top 30 price gaps
- Hurley's is cheapest for 3 of the top 30 price gaps
- The average savings across these items is $22.25 per item
- The biggest single gap is $62.01 on Seasonal Gift Baskets 75
Use our price comparison tool to check any product, or browse all compared products.
Prices as of March 2026. Based on UPC barcode matching across Cayman Islands stores.