Foster's vs Hurley's: Cayman Grocery Price Comparison
(Updated Mar 7)
We compared 4,566 products available at both Foster's and Hurley's using UPC barcode matching. Here's the verdict.
The Score
| Metric | Foster's | Hurley's |
|---|---|---|
| Win Rate | 82% | 18% |
| Cheaper On | 3759 items | 807 items |
| Avg Price | $11.75 | $6.71 |
| Total Products | 15,084 | 8,436 |
Where Foster's Wins
Products where Foster's has the better price:
Where Hurley's Wins
But it's not one-sided. These products are cheaper at the other store:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seasonal Gift Baskets 75 | $12.99 (Hurley's) | $75.00 (Foster's) | $62.01 (83%) |
| Grace Coconut Water w/ Pulp | $1.69 (Hurley's) | $35.99 (Foster's) | $34.30 (95%) |
| Chicken Caesar Wrap | $7.99 (Hurley's) | $24.99 (Foster's) | $17.00 (68%) |
| PARMIGIANO REGGIANO | $16.99 (Hurley's) | $29.99 (Foster's) | $13.00 (43%) |
| Coke Classic 6 12 Cans | $6.49 (Hurley's) | $17.49 (Foster's) | $11.00 (63%) |
| Endive Belgian Red | $9.49 (Hurley's) | $15.99 (Foster's) | $6.50 (41%) |
| Herbal Essences Hydrate Coconut Oil Conditioner 13.5 Fl Oz | $8.49 (Hurley's) | $14.89 (Foster's) | $6.40 (43%) |
| Collard Greens | $3.89 (Hurley's) | $10.29 (Foster's) | $6.40 (62%) |
| Ks Assorted Muffins 6 Pk | $3.59 (Hurley's) | $8.99 (Foster's) | $5.40 (60%) |
| Swiffer Swiffer Duster Kit With 3 Ft Extendable Handle, Heavy Duty Starter Kit With 3 Refills 1 kit | $9.59 (Hurley's) | $14.99 (Foster's) | $5.40 (36%) |
| Montchevre Plain Goat Cheese 8 oz | $9.59 (Hurley's) | $14.69 (Foster's) | $5.10 (35%) |
| Old Spice Old Spice Red Collection Deodorant For Men, Swagger Scent, 3.0oz 3 oz | $8.09 (Hurley's) | $13.09 (Foster's) | $5.00 (38%) |
| Nature Made Burp Less Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplements, 1200 mg Softgels, EPA DHA Omega 3 Fish Oil Supplements for Healthy Heart Support, 60 Softgels, 30 Day Supply | $16.19 (Hurley's) | $20.39 (Foster's) | $4.20 (21%) |
| Glazed Donuts | $1.29 (Hurley's) | $5.29 (Foster's) | $4.00 (76%) |
| Gillette Razors, Disposable, Pivot, Lubrastrip 12 ea | $10.99 (Hurley's) | $14.99 (Foster's) | $4.00 (27%) |
Verdict
Foster's is cheaper on more items overall, but Hurley's beats them on plenty of products. The best strategy? Compare prices on the items you actually buy.
Based on 4,566 UPC-matched products. Prices updated daily.