Hurley's vs Priced Right: Cayman Grocery Price Comparison
(Updated Mar 7)
We compared 84 products available at both Hurley's and Priced Right using UPC barcode matching. Here's the verdict.
The Score
| Metric | Hurley's | Priced Right |
|---|---|---|
| Win Rate | 21% | 79% |
| Cheaper On | 18 items | 66 items |
| Avg Price | $6.71 | $24.52 |
| Total Products | 8,436 | 2,600 |
Where Priced Right Wins
Products where Priced Right has the better price:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Badia Olive Oil, Extra Virgin 67.6 Oz | $32.99 (Priced Right) | $43.99 (Hurley's) | $11.00 (25%) |
| Pampers Baby-Dry Diapers, Sesame Street, Size 1 (8-14 lb), Super Pack | $28.99 (Priced Right) | $36.99 (Hurley's) | $8.00 (22%) |
| Pampers Pampers Baby Dry Diapers, Size 2 (10 22 Lbs), 112 Count, Up To 100% Leakproof Disposable Diaper 112 ct | $28.99 (Priced Right) | $36.59 (Hurley's) | $7.60 (21%) |
| Huggies Diaper, Disney Baby, 6 (Over 35 Lb) 66 ea | $29.99 (Priced Right) | $36.79 (Hurley's) | $6.80 (18%) |
| Head & Shoulders Shampoo + Conditioner, 2 In 1, Smooth & Silky 28.2 Fl Oz | $9.99 (Priced Right) | $15.49 (Hurley's) | $5.50 (36%) |
| Honeydew/White Honeydew Melon, Large | $1.79 (Priced Right) | $6.99 (Hurley's) | $5.20 (74%) |
| Huggies Diapers, Disney Baby, 5 (Over 27 Lb) 84 ea | $29.99 (Priced Right) | $34.29 (Hurley's) | $4.30 (13%) |
| Red Peppers | $3.79 (Priced Right) | $7.99 (Hurley's) | $4.20 (53%) |
| Always Always Daily Fresh Thin Liners, Regular, Unscented Panty Liners, 120 Count 120 ct | $5.99 (Priced Right) | $9.49 (Hurley's) | $3.50 (37%) |
| Green Asparagus, Small | $4.99 (Priced Right) | $8.09 (Hurley's) | $3.10 (38%) |
| Lipman Tomatoes, Grape 1 Pt | $2.99 (Priced Right) | $5.99 (Hurley's) | $3.00 (50%) |
| Carrots 5 Lb | $6.39 (Priced Right) | $8.99 (Hurley's) | $2.60 (29%) |
| Cream O Land Whole Milk 1 Gal | $5.99 (Priced Right) | $8.49 (Hurley's) | $2.50 (29%) |
| Panam Salmon Prtn Sknls | $7.49 (Priced Right) | $9.99 (Hurley's) | $2.50 (25%) |
| Panamei 200/300 Cooked Shrimp | $7.49 (Priced Right) | $9.99 (Hurley's) | $2.50 (25%) |
Where Hurley's Wins
But it's not one-sided. These products are cheaper at the other store:
| Product | Cheapest | Other Store | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grace Coconut Water w/ Pulp | $1.69 (Hurley's) | $32.89 (Priced Right) | $31.20 (95%) |
| Coke Classic 6 12 Cans | $6.49 (Hurley's) | $18.79 (Priced Right) | $12.30 (65%) |
| Ks Assorted Muffins 6 Pk | $3.59 (Hurley's) | $10.99 (Priced Right) | $7.40 (67%) |
| Dlx Diaper Bag W/ Changng Pad | $2.99 (Hurley's) | $8.99 (Priced Right) | $6.00 (67%) |
| Foska Oats 400 G | $2.19 (Hurley's) | $5.39 (Priced Right) | $3.20 (59%) |
| Broccoli | $3.99 (Hurley's) | $6.99 (Priced Right) | $3.00 (43%) |
| Malanga | $2.99 (Hurley's) | $5.79 (Priced Right) | $2.80 (48%) |
| Artichokes, Large | $4.69 (Hurley's) | $7.29 (Priced Right) | $2.60 (36%) |
| Diamond Of California Almonds, Slivered 6 oz | $7.29 (Hurley's) | $8.49 (Priced Right) | $1.20 (14%) |
| Tomatoes On The Vine | $4.89 (Hurley's) | $5.99 (Priced Right) | $1.10 (18%) |
| Granny Smith Apples, Large | $2.39 (Hurley's) | $2.99 (Priced Right) | $0.60 (20%) |
| Eggplant Japanese | $3.19 (Hurley's) | $3.79 (Priced Right) | $0.60 (16%) |
| Pink Grapefruit, Large | $1.99 (Hurley's) | $2.39 (Priced Right) | $0.40 (17%) |
| Regular Eggplant (Aubergine) | $2.89 (Hurley's) | $3.29 (Priced Right) | $0.40 (12%) |
| Fuji Apples, Large | $2.39 (Hurley's) | $2.69 (Priced Right) | $0.30 (11%) |
Verdict
Priced Right is cheaper on more items overall, but Hurley's beats them on plenty of products. The best strategy? Compare prices on the items you actually buy.
Based on 84 UPC-matched products. Prices updated daily.